Can Dogs Eat Nutter Butters?

Canines are notoriously voracious eaters, and many pet owners lavish their dogs with human food as gifts.

What’s not to love about Nutter Butters? What’s not to love about soft, creamy peanut butter spread between two delightful little wafers fashioned like charming peanuts?

Because many people adore Nutter Butters, you may be wondering if you may offer it to your dog as a treat. They do, after all, resemble dog biscuits!

But are Nutter Butters safe for dogs to eat? Some argue that Nutter Butters are harmful for dogs since they are high in fat, salt, and sugar. Others, however, argue that Nutter Butters are OK in moderation.

Although ordinary Nutter Butters are not poisonous to dogs, it is still best if they do not consume this treat. This piece will explain why and what alternatives you have for your dog.

So, what really is the truth? Can dogs consume Nutter Butters? If your dog eats a Nutter Butter, what should you do? Continue reading to find out!

Why Are Nutter Butters Dangerous To My Dog?

Nutter Butters are high in carbohydrates, fats, and chemical preservatives, which are hazardous to dogs.

The most important thing to remember is that humans can process little amounts of these components; even so, if a person is not used to consuming anything like this, they will get unwell.

Dogs’ bodies may not have the same capacities as humans to digest the many food-based compounds that are often added to human food. If you give your dog something like Nutter Butter and its body isn’t used to it or can’t handle it, it could get very sick.

In fact, one chemical in many artificially sweetened snacks is particularly dangerous to dogs. According to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the chemical xylitol is contained in many artificially sweetened foods, including sugar-free confectionery, thin ice cream, baked goods, and even peanut and Nutter Butter cookies.

When swallowed, this substance can induce abrupt weakness, reductions in blood pressure, collapse, seizures, and even death in dogs.

Almost everything you read about the chemical xylitol concerning dogs is unfavorable. There is no specific quantity of the chemical that might induce such negative effects.

In smaller dog breeds, the amount ingested may create more severe problems than in more giant breeds. Overall, it’s better to be safe than sorry and avoid giving your dog a Nutter Butter.

Is Peanut Butter Safe For Dogs?

Yes! Natural peanut butter, free of chemicals, sweeteners, and preservatives, is good in modest amounts for non-allergic dogs.

However, the peanut butter filling included in Nutter Butters is not suitable for dogs.

In addition, xylitol is a component present in several kinds of peanut butter. Low-sugar or diet goods that are touted as healthy often include xylitol as an artificial sweetener. While this is true for people, it is not true for dogs because xylitol is exceedingly harmful to them.

Although the peanut butter in Nutter Butters does not include xylitol, it has other artificial substances that make it unsuitable for your dog.

Don’t give your dog anything but natural peanut butter as a reward.

What Will Happen If My Dog Eats Nutter Butters?

Imagine eating something your stomach can’t handle. Perhaps you are gluten-free and, by accident, swallowed anything containing gluten?

Your dog may experience severe pain and suffering if you give them a Nutter Butter or other similar treat. If your dog consumes these items, it may have nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, or even more severe problems. When your dog shows these undesirable traits, you’ll have to deal with the aftermath.

So, My Dog Ate Some Nutter Butters. Now What?

The essential thing is to remain calm if your dog was served Nutter Butters without knowing the hazards or if he broke into a package.

Remember that, while they aren’t healthy and may make him sick, peanut butter Nutter Butters will not poison your dog.

Make sure he gets access to his usual dog food and lots of water to wash out all sugar and toxins. In addition, keep an eye on your dog for the following 24 hours to see whether he vomits or has diarrhea. It’s still OK if he does – this is simply his body’s technique of absorbing those foreign components that he cannot process.

If your dog continues to vomit after a few hours or displays signs of lethargy and refuses to eat after a day, take him to the vet. And, of course, move the remaining Nutter Butters out of reach of him, and encourage your family and friends to do the same.

I Want To Make A Peanut Butter Treat For My Dog… What Should I Present To Them?

Several fantastic peanut butter dog treats recipes require minimal baking talent. Furthermore, dogs don’t have a sophisticated palate regarding their delicacies; thus, they are your most ardent food critic.

An apple with peanut butter is one of the most simple treats you can prepare for your dog. Just ensure to remove the core, seeds, and the stem of the apple and to use natural peanut butter without any additives.

On the other hand, you may find many great treats for your dog at your neighborhood grocery store or pet supply shop.

These snacks shouldn’t contain odd or hazardous ingredients such as corn, sugar, or soy and are beneficial to your dog.

Even better, these treat delicacies are available from various online shops that can send them straight to your home. So there will be no baking and no shopping.


Everyone like giving their pets treats, especially when their dog accomplishes something deserving of one. Unfortunately, what is a delight for us may harm a dog.

Dogs should not consume Nutter Butters due to the artificial, processed components and sugar level. If your dog swallows any, keep an eye out for symptoms of vomiting or sickness.

Always seek the most natural, unadulterated, high-quality foods you can discover. When purchasing peanut butter or any other type of treat, search for the chemical xylitol, which is hazardous to dogs.

Finally, remember to love your dog and ensure that anything you offer them is joyful and healthy.

Further Reading:

Similar Posts